Amazon Package Inserts: The 3 Most Common Mistakes
Package inserts are one of the most commonly used tools in e-commerce. To put it simply, package inserts are printed materials included inside a product's packaging. They're the small cards, flyers, or booklets customers discover when they open their order. While easy to overlook, package inserts can play a powerful role in shaping the post-purchase experience.
E-commerce brands use package inserts in many different ways, including:
product instructions or setup guides
care, safety, or warranty information
thank you notes and brand story cards
customer support contact details
cross-selling or product education
requests for customer feedback or reviews
When done well, package inserts reduce returns, answer common questions, improve customer satisfaction and reinforce brand trust. To see real-life examples of different inserts, check out InsertBooth.com.
For many brands - especially those selling on marketplaces like Amazon - package inserts are one of the few direct touchpoints they have with customers after the sale.
However, this is also where problems start.
Because package inserts are a direct channel, what feels like a harmless sentence or friendly design choice can quickly cross into territory Amazon considers review manipulation.
Many sellers can get into trouble, not because they're trying to break the rules, but because they:
copy insert templates from other sellers
follow outdated advice
don't realize visuals and wording are evaluated just as strictly as text
In this article, we'll break down the three most common reasons sellers get in trouble when using package inserts on Amazon.
The 3 Most Common Mistakes
1. Asking Happy Customers for 5-Star Reviews and Sending Unhappy Customers Elsewhere
This is the #1 mistake sellers make. A very common insert says something like:
If you're happy with your purchase, please leave us a 5-star review ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. If you're unhappy, contact us at support@brand.com [your e-mail].
While this may seem customer-friendly, Amazon considers this review manipulation. This prohibits Amazon's policies because you're specifically asking for positive or 5-star reviews, diverting dissatisfied customers away from Amazon's review system, and creating a biased review funnel.
2. Using Smiley Faces, Icons, or Visual 5-Star Cues
Even if your wording seems neutral, visual elements alone can violate Amazon's policies. Many sellers get flagged for inserts that include:
faces representing satisfaction levels 🙂 ☹️ 😐
a row of ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ icons
graphics that visually imply "5 stars = good, fewer stars = bad"
Amazon considers visual cues just as influential as text. If your insert emphasizes 5 stars visually, encourages customers to associate positive actions with higher ratings, and suggests a preferred outcome, it can still be interpreted as review manipulation.
3. Explicitly Asking Customers to Leave a 5-Star Review
This one seems obvious, but it still happens frequently. Examples include:
"Please leave us a 5-star review."
"5-star reviews help our small business."
"If you enjoyed the product, give us five stars."
Amazon wants to ensure their system is voluntary, unbiased, and free from seller influence.
Package inserts aren’t banned—but how you use them matters.
Most sellers who get into trouble didn’t intend to break the rules. They simply copied insert templates that look harmless but violate Amazon’s policies in subtle ways.
When it comes to Amazon reviews, remember this rule of thumb:
If your insert tries to influence who leaves a review or how many stars they give, it’s probably not compliant.
Package inserts are one of the few marketing assets you have complete creative control over inside an Amazon order — but that advantage disappears quickly when the execution is off. A vague call-to-action, a generic offer that gives customers no real reason to act, or a direct policy violation that puts your seller account at risk can turn what should be your highest-converting touchpoint into dead weight in the box. The good news is that all three mistakes are entirely avoidable.
Get the messaging tight, make the value obvious within the first two seconds of reading, and stay firmly within Amazon's guidelines — and your insert stops being an afterthought and starts being one of the most cost-effective tools in your post-purchase strategy. The brands winning on Amazon aren't just the ones with the best products. They're the ones who understand that the sale is just the beginning of the relationship.
Here are some more helpful guides on Amazon compliance:
What is GetReviews.ai?
GetReviews.ai is a tool designed for e-commerce sellers on Amazon, Walmart, and more to increase post-purchase customer engagement platform through QR codes, and survey flows and help generate more authentic, compliant product reviews and build stronger relationships with their customers after every sale.
Book a demo today to learn more: